Bitbucket vs Github vs Sourceforge vs Beanstalk : 2015

Every software projects has various levels of development, and the most important thing is to have a version control system. Version control system not only provides a backup of the code for every version, but allows a collaborative team approach in working on the software. For this, various tools like CVS, SVN, Git, Bazaar and Mercurial have been developed. In this article, we are going the websites which provide a cloud based online hosting for such tools and in that, discuss the features of github, bitbucket, beanstalk and sourceforge and compare them. But before that, let’s have a look over CVS, SVN, Bazaar, Git and Mercurial and the advantages associated with them.

bitbucket vs github

Version Control Systems

CVS which is the acronym for Concurrent Version System, is a client-server revision control system, and yes, it was the first and foremost of its kind. Later, subversion (SVN) came into the picture, and took over the whole screen. From Google code to source forge, from development of open source to every great software, SVN worked behind everywhere the scenes. SVN provided a heck lot of features over the traditional CVS such as feature/bug tracking etc. Bazaar also came into the scenes but lasted a very small age. Though big projects like Ubuntu adopted it at early stage, but due to maintenance, it didn’t end long. Mercurial and Git came up as DVCS (Distributed CVS) , and whoop, they took over the world. Nothing frantic, but git and mercurial have a lot and lot of features over the previous version control system, and will be discussed in detail in another blog post. The detailed comparison is below.

Bitbucket vs Github vs Sourceforge vs Beanstalk

Sourceforge

So coming back to where we were, let’s dig into the history a little bit. It all started with SourceForge. The father of all version control online hosting websites, sourceforge started in 1999, and was the first open source website of its kind. The source code of sourceforge software itself was available to public for free, but later after November 2001, no more versions were released for public.  Over the years, it not only served as online CVS, but added the features of bug tracking, feature requests, download mirrors, and yes, it provides a free website for all the open source projects hosted on it. Currently it supports all the major version control systems, viz, CVS, SVN, Bazaar, Git and Mercurial. The one important part is that SourceForge provides only open source projects hosting. One distracting thing is the advertisements on the website, but every service needs some revenue, so its cool.

  • First version control hosting
  • Only open source projects
  • Download Mirrors
  • Bug tracking
  • Feature requests
  • CVS, SVN, Bazaar, Git and Mercurial support

Github

Github started in 2008, and was the first solution to provide GIT support. The flexibility with DCVS and GIT tempted many software developers round the globe to switch to GIT, and thus ultimately to Github. It is also a community maintained platform, and the various tools are developed and enhanced by developers, all open source. Today, Github is the most widely used for open source project development, and has a lot of benefits over its peers. The premium account on github allows hosting of private repositories too, which helps in building private projects, and the free version is essentially open source. Github also provides a lot of features, some of them being simple one click forking, github gists, github websites, pull request feature, issue trackers, commit comments, easy source control and what not! Eclipse plugin support is also a great feature by github, which allows everything directly from the IDE. Automatic testers like Jenkins move the feature list even more upwards. It supports GIT and Mercurial only. Adding to it, a nice and simple User Interface keeps it the best for open source projects.

  • Most widely used for open source projects
  • Great UI
  • First to support GIT, supports Mercurial too
  • One click Forking & Starring
  • Two click Pull Request
  • Pull Request and Issue tracker support
  • Github gists and pages
  • Automatic code testers like Jenkins
  • Free for open source only, premium accounts for private repositories

Bitbucket

Next, developed by Atlassian, Bitbucket is another foremost online SVCS hosting website which provides almost all the features as Github, and more that that, provides unlimited number of private repositories for up to 5 users. Although it is not as widely used as Github, but it is a tough competitor to it, and many startups and small companies use bitbucket for project hosting. It also provides support for hipchat notifications and github gists like snippets. It also features JIRA, Confluence and Bamboo for tracking, collaboration and continuous integration. It also supports GIT and Mercurial only, and is a tough competitor to Github.

  • Tough competitor to Github
  • Almost all features of Github
  • Free private repositories for up to 5 users
  • Support for Hipchat
  • Features JIRA, Confluence and Bamboo

Beanstalk

Beanstalk, launched in 2007, is a private GIT and SVN hosting. It falls back as it is free just for one user and one repository, and that too limited to 100 MB. The premium accounts of Beanstalk do provide a lot of features, but not as much as Github and Bitbucket. One major feature is the FTP support for the repositories, which is not provided by other version control hosting websites, which makes it easier to push the code online and share with collaborators. But still, it is a very less widely used online version control repository hosting, and subservient than others.

  • Less used
  • Free for just one user and one repository
  • FTP support
  • GIT and SVN support

So, concluding, if you have an open source project, go for Github; if you are a startup and have a small team, go for Bitbucket and enjoy its free private repositories, and if you live in 2000s, go for sourceforge 😀

Sourceforge Github Bitbucket Beanstalk
Version Control Systems CVS, SVN, Bazaar, GIT, Mercurial GIT, Mercurial GIT, Mercurial GIT, SVN
Projects Only Open Source Famous for open source, supports private repos Open source, Private Private
Pricing Free Free for public repositories, and free premium account for students Unlimited public and private repositories for up to 5 users One repository, one user free
UI/UX Old fashioned, ambiguous Great UI/UX Great UI/UX Average
Others Download mirrors Automatic testing etc Hipchat, Bamboo, JIRA, Conluence FTP

2 Comments

  1. Bryan September 16, 2015
    • admin September 26, 2015

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *